The plaintiffs were former employees of Company H who had worked under indefinite-term employment contracts until reaching the mandatory retirement age. Under a collective bargaining agreement with the labor union, Company H agreed to extend the mandatory retirement age from 59 to 60 in exchange for introducing a wage-peak system, under which employees’ wages would be adjusted beginning at age 57 for a three-year period. The company also adopted and amended its rules of employment to reflect the arrangement.

The plaintiffs challenged the validity of the wage-peak system and sought payment of the wages reduced under the system. They argued that (i) their individual employment contracts provided more favorable terms and should therefore prevail over the collective bargaining agreement or the amended rules of employment; (ii) the introduction of the wage-peak system constituted a disadvantageous amendment to the rules of employment that required their individual consent, which had not been obtained; and (iii) the system was invalid because it violated Article 4-4(1) of the Act on Prohibition of Age Discrimination in Employment and Elderly Employment Promotion (the “Elderly Employment Act”) and Article 8(1) of the Equal Employment Opportunity and Work-Family Balance Assistance Act.

Representing Company H, Shin & Kim challenged each of these arguments. First, Shin & Kim argued that the principle giving precedence to more favorable individual employment terms did not apply because the plaintiffs had neither executed separate written employment contracts nor entered into individual agreements establishing such terms.

Second, Shin & Kim argued that Company H had properly obtained the collective consent required under the proviso to Article 94(1) of the Labor Standards Act, including by entering into a collective bargaining agreement with the union representing a majority of employees and obtaining written confirmations of the amendments to the rules of employment.

Third, Shin & Kim argued that the wage-peak system was introduced in conjunction with an extension of the mandatory retirement age and constituted a necessary measure involving wage-structure reform under Article 19-2 of the Elderly Employment Act. Shin & Kim further pointed out that the system applied higher payment rates to indefinite-term employees than to regular employees: over the three-year wage-peak period, regular employees received a cumulative total of 195 percent of their compensation immediately before entering the wage-peak system, while indefinite-term employees, including the plaintiffs, received 210 percent. Company H also continued to reflect wage increases in their compensation and implemented appropriate compensatory measures, including reduced workloads, the same employee benefits, conversion to a defined contribution retirement pension scheme, and training programs. Shin & Kim emphasized that, taken together, these circumstances demonstrated that the wage-peak system did not constitute age discrimination without reasonable justification.

The court accepted all of Shin & Kim’s arguments and dismissed the plaintiffs’ claims in their entirety.