1. Introduction
Despite ongoing efforts by businesses and governments to prevent industrial accidents, work-related injuries continue to occur. Employers must therefore be prepared not only to prevent industrial accidents but also to respond effectively when they occur.
Industrial accidents can give rise to various legal disputes, including lawsuits seeking damages for work-related injuries. These proceedings can expose employers to financial liability, and determining the amount of compensation payable is often a complex process. Damages may include lost earnings and other economic losses, medical and care expenses, and non-pecuniary damages for mental suffering. Calculating the injured employee’s losses is only the first step: the final amount payable by the employer also depends on how the employee’s own negligence affects the employer’s share of liability and how compensation already received, including workers’ compensation insurance benefits, should be deducted.
This article examines the principal issues that arise when calculating damages in lawsuits involving work-related injuries, with a focus on matters that employers and their HR and employment professionals should understand.
Under established Supreme Court precedent, tort damages are divided into three categories: lost earnings and other lost economic benefits (passive damages), expenses incurred as a result of the injury (active damages), and non-pecuniary damages for mental suffering. Each category is treated as a distinct claim (Supreme Court Decision 76Da1313 dated October 12, 1976, etc.). The same classification applies to damages claims arising from work-related injuries. The following sections examine the key issues associated with each category of damages.
2. Lost Earnings and Other Economic Losses (Passive Damages)
Passive damages refer to economic benefits that the injured person would have earned but for the tortious act (i.e. industrial accidents). Lost future earnings are a principal example.
A. Two Approaches to Calculating Lost Earnings
There are two theoretical approaches to calculating passive damages: the earning-capacity approach and the income-difference approach. Under the earning-capacity approach, the loss itself is the impairment of the injured person’s capacity to work, and damages are calculated by assessing the value of that lost earning capacity—generally by reference to the person’s income at the time of the tortious act. By contrast, the income-difference approach treats the loss as the reduction in income resulting from the tortious act, calculating damages based on the difference between the injured person’s income at the time of the tortious act and their income afterward.
In practice, Korean courts calculate passive damages using the earning-capacity approach. Under this approach, once a loss of earning capacity has been established, income actually earned after the tortious act does not affect the calculation of damages.
B. Income Used to Calculate Lost Earnings
In work-related injury cases, the injured person is generally a wage-earning employee. The employee’s actual income at the time of the accident serves as the basis for calculating lost earnings (Supreme Court Decision 94Da26134 dated September 27, 1994, etc.). The calculation need not be based on the employee’s statutory average wages or ordinary wages (Supreme Court Decision 94Da60257 dated September 29, 1995). Where income before the accident was objectively verifiable and consistent, the court may use average earnings over the preceding three months or one year, or even earnings from a single month, as the basis for calculation (Damages Litigation Practice: Traffic Accidents and Occupational Injuries, revised ed. 2017, pp. 120–121).
The Supreme Court has also held that, where the prevailing daily wage for a general worker in an urban area exceeds the injured employee’s actual income, lost earnings may be calculated using that higher wage (Supreme Court en banc Decision 79Da1899 dated February 26, 1980). Conversely, even where the employee’s actual income exceeds that prevailing wage, courts generally use the prevailing wage to calculate lost earnings for the period between the employee’s mandatory retirement age and the end of the recognized working-life period (age 65; Supreme Court en banc Decision 2018Da248909 dated February 21, 2019).
Where the injured employee has died, living expenses equivalent to one-third of income are deducted when determining lost earnings.
C. Assessing the Loss of Earning Capacity
As noted above, courts generally calculate passive damages based on the percentage of earning capacity lost by the injured person. This percentage is ultimately a matter for the court to determine, taking into account all relevant circumstances, including the medical expert’s assessment. While the court is not required to adopt the medical expert’s assessment without modification (Supreme Court Decision 93Da53719 dated March 8, 1994), medical assessments nevertheless have a substantial influence on the court’s determination.
The questions submitted to the medical expert are therefore particularly important. Parties and their legal representatives should carefully prepare the questionnaire attached to the request for a medical examination submitted to the medical institution, as the framing of the questions can affect the resulting assessment even when the same medical records are used.
3. Medical and Care Expenses (Active Damages)
Active damages refer to expenses incurred by the injured person as a result of a tortious act, such as hospitalization and outpatient treatment costs.
A. Past Medical Expenses
Not every expense incurred in connection with treatment is necessarily recoverable. For example, the Supreme Court has held that additional costs associated with admission to a special hospital room rather than a standard room generally cannot be regarded as damages having an adequate causal connection to the tortious act unless special circumstances justify the expense—such as a physician’s determination that transfer to a special room was unavoidable or that the nature of the treatment required admission to such a room (Supreme Court Decision 94Da39413 dated March 14, 1995).
B. Future Medical Expenses
Where treatment has not been completed at the time of the medical examination and further treatment is expected to be necessary, estimated future medical expenses are included in the calculation of damages. Likewise, the court determines future medical expenses after considering the medical expert’s findings and all other relevant circumstances.
C. Past and Future Care Expenses
Where an employee suffers a serious injury and requires assistance from another person during treatment or because of a residual disability after treatment, the costs of such past and future care are also included in the calculation of damages. Depending on the employee’s condition, care may be required for a specified period or for the remainder of the employee’s life.
In determining future care expenses, courts consider the medical evidence and other relevant circumstances, including the duration of care, the number of hours of assistance required each day, and the number of caregivers needed. For example, in Supreme Court Decision 2015Da5712 dated June 11, 2015, the Court found that the injured person required approximately eight hours of daily care by an adult caregiver, compensable at the urban daily labor wage rate, from the date of the accident until the end of the person’s expected remaining life expectancy.
Future care expenses can increase substantially where the injured person requires more than eight hours of daily assistance or multiple caregivers. In Supreme Court Decision 2013Da18332 dated December 24, 2014, the Court determined that an injured person in a vegetative state required 12 hours of daily care, equivalent to the services of 1.5 adult caregivers.
The duration and intensity of required care can therefore have a significant effect on the damages calculation. Where future care expenses are anticipated, parties and their legal representatives often vigorously contest the appropriate basis for calculating those expenses, relying on medical assessments and relevant judicial precedents.
4. Deduction of Insurance Benefits and Comparative Negligence
In work-related injury cases, injured employees often receive workers’ compensation insurance benefits from the Korea Workers’ Compensation and Welfare Service under the Industrial Accident Compensation Insurance Act. The workers’ compensation insurance benefits that have already been received by the injured employee must be deducted from the corresponding damages (deduction of insurance benefits). And the portion of damages to which the injured employee’s own negligence (comparative negligence) contributed must be also deducted.
A. Order of Deduction
The order in which these adjustments are applied can affect the final amount payable. Previously, Supreme Court precedent required comparative negligence to be applied first, followed by the deduction of insurance benefits. However, in its en banc Decision 2021Da241618 dated March 24, 2022, the Supreme Court departed from its previous approach and held that the relevant insurance benefits must be deducted first, with comparative negligence applied afterward.
B. Deduction of Insurance Benefits from Corresponding Losses Only
Insurance benefits may be deducted only from the specific category of damages they are intended to compensate; an excess payment in one category cannot be used to reduce damages in another category.
For example, suppose an injured employee suffers KRW 1 million in active damages and KRW 1 million in passive damages, and receives KRW 1.2 million in insurance benefits corresponding to active damages and KRW 500,000 corresponding to passive damages.
Because the insurance benefits for active damages exceed the KRW 1 million loss, no uncompensated active damages remain. However, the excess KRW 200,000 cannot be deducted from passive damages. Only the KRW 500,000 in benefits corresponding to passive damages may be deducted from the KRW 1 million passive loss, leaving KRW 500,000 in uncompensated passive damages.
C. Application of Comparative Negligence
The court determines the degree of the injured employee’s comparative negligence after considering all relevant circumstances presented during the proceedings. Continuing the example above, if KRW 500,000 in passive damages remains after the deduction of insurance benefits and the injured employee is found to be 20 percent at fault for the accident, the employer’s liability for those damages would be KRW 400,000 (KRW 500,000 × 80 percent).
In practice, parties commonly submit evidence concerning the circumstances of the accident and dispute the relative degrees of negligence attributable to the employer and the injured employee.
5. Non-Pecuniary Damages
Non-pecuniary damages compensate an injured person for mental suffering and are not subject to the deduction of insurance benefits or comparative negligence.
The court determines the amount after considering all relevant circumstances presented during the proceedings. Factors relating to the injured person include the location and severity of the injury, the location and extent of any residual disability, age, sex, occupation, financial circumstances, and educational background.
The court also considers circumstances relating to the party responsible for the injury, including that party’s financial circumstances, the manner and circumstances of the wrongful conduct, and whether the conduct was intentional or negligent.
6. Settlement Agreements and the Risk of Subsequent Claims
Employers and injured employees may seek to resolve work-related injury disputes through settlement rather than litigation. A typical settlement provides that the employer will pay an agreed amount and that the employee will waive all claims arising from the work-related injury. Where such an agreement is valid and enforceable, a subsequent damages lawsuit brought by the employee against the employer will be dismissed on procedural grounds or on the merits.
However, a settlement does not necessarily eliminate all risk of future litigation. The scope and enforceability of a settlement may be limited by its terms and the circumstances under which it was concluded. Depending on those circumstances, a court may find that no valid agreement was formed, that the agreement is void as an unfair juristic act, or that it may be rescinded on grounds of mistake.
Particular care is required where additional harm that the parties did not anticipate when entering into the agreement emerges after settlement. Depending on the circumstances, courts may permit claims for such subsequently arising damages notwithstanding an earlier settlement (Supreme Court Decision 99Da42797 dated September 14, 2001, etc.). Employers should therefore draft settlement agreements with these considerations in mind to reduce the risk of subsequent claims.
7. Conclusion
Work-related injury damages litigation involves determining the injured employee’s losses and the amount of compensation payable, a process that raises numerous calculation issues. While disputes over the basis of liability remain important, employers should also understand the various components of the damages calculation to avoid an excessive assessment of damages if liability is established. Where employers seek to resolve disputes through settlement rather than litigation, settlement agreements should be carefully drafted to minimize the risk of subsequent claims.
* This article is a summary of an article published in the October issue of Monthly Labor Law.
